Peachey’s Baking Co

Oxana Oxana 2 months ago

If you’re looking for the best donuts, this is the place! They are always incredibly fresh, soft, and absolutely delicious. One of my favorite things is that you can actually watch them being made, so you know they’re fresh right out of the fryer. They taste homemade, yet they’re light and never greasy. The staff is always kind, welcoming, and incredibly efficient. Service is fast, even when it’s busy. I absolutely love this place and stop by whenever I have the chance. Highly recommended!

Fab 3 months ago

I’d definitely recommend this place and the coolest things is that they make the donuts right in front of you. While you’re waiting in the (usually long) line, you can watch them shape the dough, let it proof, fry the donuts, and glaze them. By the time it’s your turn to order, the donuts have literally just come out of the fryer, so they’re still warm and incredibly fresh. They’re light, soft, with just a slight gooey texture inside, and the glaze adds the perfect amount of sweetness without being overpowering. Freshly made, warm donuts are on a completely different level!

Sonali Khandwala 3 months ago

Peachy's Bakery was, without exaggeration, the best doughnuts I have ever had in my life. We went on Friday for National Donut Day while visiting family in Sarasota, and they were the ones who introduced us to it—very appropriately, as it felt like walking into something a little dangerous in the best way. The line was out the door, and they had clearly already sold out multiple times that morning, but what stood out was how efficiently they kept everything moving and how smoothly they were still getting fresh donuts out despite the rush. We tried a mix: glazed, cinnamon sugar, a pretzel, and the chocolate ganache. Not a single one disappointed. They were perfectly doughy, warm, and full of flavor in a way that makes it hard to imagine going back to a regular donut after this. My cousin also got the glazed donut latte iced, which I regretted not ordering myself the moment I tried a sip. Honestly, I would fly back to Sarasota just for these. Even the next day, the ones we brought back still tasted great—which says everything.

Veronika Trifonova 4 months ago

Peachey’s Baking Co. is such a great spot. The space itself feels bright, clean, and minimal in the best way — almost like a modern bakery mixed with a little coastal café charm. The donuts were absolutely delicious. They had the perfect fresh, homemade texture — soft, airy, slightly chewy, and not overly heavy or greasy. The chocolate donut especially stood out because it was glazed underneath the chocolate frosting, which made it extra rich and flavorful without being overwhelming. We also tried the original glazed and the pretzel, and both were a huge hit as well. Everything tasted incredibly fresh and thoughtfully made.

Zuly 6 months ago

We travel two hours just to come here, and it’s absolutely worth it every time. These are hands down the best doughnuts we’ve ever tried. They’re huge, incredibly soft, and served warm. The glaze is amazing—sweet, fresh, and sooo good. We also attended the grand opening of this location, and it was a great experience. Everything was well organized, the atmosphere was fun, and the doughnuts were just as delicious as always. Definitely a place we’ll keep making the trip for!